Vintage magician on a poster surrounded by magic muses and mythical objects.

Best Magicians of All Time

A friend challenged me to post a list of the best magicians of all time. It’s of course an impossible job to say who are the best magicians ever. Let alone to say who is the number one magician in the world. It’s not like in sports. As soon as you don’t have something objective like an athlete’s performance record as your scale, ‘the best’ is just a subjective minefield. Nevertheless, to meet my friend’s challenge, here I go… 

What is the Measuring Stick?

To be a great artist or craftsman, first you’ve got to understand and master what you’ve inherited from those who came before you. That’s the ‘standing on the shoulders of giants’ idea. From there, you have to take that inheritance into new directions that are influenced by your own identity and ideas. Which of those identities and ideas are more innovative than the another person’s is of course a matter of opinion. And what about the artist’s long-term impact? Their skill? How famous or revered are they to the public or their peers? How financially successful were they? How much did they change the playing field?

My Criteria

So, aware of the challenges when answering a question like this, I’ve put on my flak jacket and I’m going out. I limited my list to 10 (it felt like a good number). I only shortlisted contenders who have performed for more than 35 years. And I picked people for the variety of different reasons listed above. Tell me in the comments if you’re surprised that your favourite magician did not make the list! I told you it was hard. But hey ho, that’s the name of this game.

The Best Magicians of All Time: My List

Adelaide Herrmann (British) (1853-1932)

Surprised to see a woman on the list? Keep reading to find out why! (Magic seriously needs more women magicians by the way. Despite big advances in recent years, still women are sorely under-represented in the world of magic. Rant over.) I did not have to make any special concessions though to include Adelaide Herrmann as one of the best magicians of all time. She was an outlier both in her time and today as the most famous female magician in history. Here’s a great short video about how she earned the title ‘The Queen of Magic’.

Adelaide began her magic career as a magician’s assistant to her husband Alexander Herrmann. She transformed his show, turning it into a true spectacle with lavish sets and a full orchestra. When he died in 1896, she was 43 years old and very soon she went on performing solo until she was 73! She said “I shall not be content until I am recognized by the public as a leader in my profession, and entirely irrespective of the question of sex.” Her favourite illusion is said to be The Phantom Bride, that had themes of marriage and loss. In it, a ‘bride’ wearing a white cloak levitated high above a bright stage before she disappeared in mid-air.

Harry Houdini (Hungarian / American) (1874-1926)

Harry Houdini is the magician who needs no introduction. This was thanks to his expertise as a marketer and showman who carefully managed his reputation and the stories that circulated about him. He was even caught standing on his tip toes for photos to project the image of being taller than he actually was. A fiercely competitive character, Houdini managed to become a household name worldwide. One media stunt he pulled was to fool the creator of Sherlock Holmes himself, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle! Harry Houdini’s fame and mastery of the media of his day is remarkable. And it is even more impressive to understand he achieved all that he did before he died at the age of 52.

Houdini reached moderate levels of success as a magician. But it all changed when at the age of 27 he decided his ‘USP’ was going to be to restyle himself as ‘The Handcuff King’ and become an escape artist par excellence. Houdini’s name is so well known now that I have met people who have heard about him and thought he was a recent historic figure, having no idea that he died in 1926! He has captured the imaginations of generations both in life and death as one of the best magicians of all time. 

Related articles:
7 Best Films About Magicians
Magicians in Film
Do You Know These 13 Types of Magicians?

Dai Vernon (Canadian) (1894-1992)

Following on from Houdini, the natural bridge from Vaudeville magicians from the Golden Age of Magic to modern ones is Dai Vernon. Nicknamed ‘The Professor,’ he boasted to have performed the trick that fooled Houdini. Vernon is probably the most influential magician to living magicians today, whether they know it or not. Alex Romanoff and Vanishing Inc. made this brilliant video introduction to Vernon here.

Many magicians say Vernon is the most skilful sleight of hand magician who ever lived. He was an expert performing with cards, coins and other small items. His teachings have inspired generations of magicians after him. He spent his life travelling all over the USA in search of famous card cheats so he could glean secret techniques to apply to magic. Vernon spent the last 30 years of his life as the resident magician at the world-famous Magic Castle in Hollywood, mentoring countless magicians who passed through the Castle’s hallowed halls.

Doug Henning (Canadian) (1947-2000)

Doug Henning is on my list because he paved the way for contemporary magic as we know it today. Doug appeared on television almost out of the blue after decades of magic being almost a footnote on the entertainment spectrum. Before Doug, the only thing people thought of when they imagined a magician was a man in a dinner jacket and top hat. Here’s Doug’s performance of The Vanishing Elephant.

Then came Doug Henning. He dressed like a flower child and he won the hearts and imaginations of audiences on television and on stage in unprecedented ways. He starred in a hit musical called The Magic Show on Broadway that ran from 1974 to 1978. On the back of that, Doug starred in 7 annual TV specials called Doug Henning’s World of Magic from 1975 onwards. The debut special brought 50 million Americans to their TV sets when it aired. Mark Wilson had been a prolific pioneer magician on early American television. Siegfried and Roy (below) had been making big splashes in magic in Las Vegas. But with his achievements, Doug Henning was a household name, toured the United States and starred in commercials on the back of his fame. The demand for magic nowadays is largely thanks to the ball he set in motion.

Siegfried & Roy (German / American)
(Siegfried 1939-2021, Roy 1944-2020)

‘Legendary’ is a term you’d expect for a magician. But few magicians live up to the term as much as Siegfried and Roy. They ruled the Las Vegas magic world for 30 years, running 48 weeks a year. Their fame came from the white lions and tigers in their act. This video shows ‘legendary’ truly applies to their achievements.

As Siegfried said in an interview with Barbara Walters, in showbiz you don’t just need to be good, you need to be different. And when he started performing with Roy and his big cats, Siegfried found what would make him different. They took their act from cruise ships to Monte Carlo to Las Vegas. Vegas producers told them ‘magic does not work in this town.’ But their act was magic like no one had ever seen before. So they single-handedly (with their team) changed the Vegas rules and thanks to them, Vegas has been a mecca for magic ever since. 

Max Maven (American) (1950-2022)

Max Maven is considered to be one of the most influential mentalist magicians of all time. Despite appearing on television throughout his career, he was much less known to the general public than others on my list. However Max was a galactic legend among magicians. He had an encyclopaedic knowledge of his field. He thought it was vital to preserve magic’s history and give credit where credit is due. As a result, he was an avid magic historian that magicians relied on for advice for decades.

Cinema legend Orson Wells described Max Maven as “the most creative mind in magic.” Max served as consultant to other magic greats including Mark Wilson, Harry Blackstone Jr, Doug Henning, Penn & Teller and Siegfried and Roy. He was generous with his expertise. I did not know him personally so I was impressed by his willingness to help me with information on an article about close-up magic on this blog as well. 

Eugene Burger (American) (1939-2017)

Different from other fields that are bigger than the magic world, one special aspect of magic is that you can meet and learn from your idols. That was exactly the case with me and Eugene Burger. I had admired his writings for years and decided to reach out for advice about my act. That was the beginning of a years-long relationship with this game-changing character in the world of magic. Eugene specialised in close-up magic and made his home on the Chicago scene. Magic networks worldwide also took him to teach at conventions and seminars. Here Eugene performs one of his signature routines, a classic of magic called The Hindu Thread.

Eugene observed that many magicians trivialised magic. Throughout his life and in his writings, he inspired magicians around the world to question this approach. As a performer, he was drawn to ‘bizaare magic.’ Eugene appeared as an unforgettable character with his booming baritone voice and sage-like magician’s beard. As a teacher, his impressive output of over 20 best-selling books and videos will continue to influence magicians in countless ways, regardless of the type of magic they do. 

David Copperfield (American) (born 1956)

David Copperfield was named by Forbes as the most commercially successful magician in history. As of 2006 he had grossed over $4 billion USD, by far more than any solo performer in entertainment history. But Copperfield is far more than a commercially successful magic legend. When Doug Henning’s career started to falter, David Copperfield appeared as he forged a unique style of theatrical storytelling magic. Copperfield’s brand was developed over the years in close collaboration with people like Joanie Spina, Chris Kenner and Homer Liwag.

Copperfield was the first magician I ever saw. I went with my family to one of his performances when I was seven years old and I immediately ‘caught the magic bug’. To this day I can play back moments of that show like a film in my mind. His list of spectacular achievements defy belief; including having made the Statue of Liberty to disappear, walking through the Great Wall of China, breaking 9 Guinness World Records, broadcasting over 20 television specials, and currently performing in 15 shows a week in Las Vegas… need I say more?

Penn & Teller (American) (Penn born 1955, Teller Born 1948)

Pioneers of their own brand of magic, Penn & Teller have worked together since the late 1970’s. Penn is the tall loud mouth and Teller is the little guy who doesn’t speak (on stage at least!). Their trademark was the ‘bad boys of magic’. This is because they pushed the boundaries of magic by challenging the adage that a magician never reveals their secrets. Far from gratuitously revealing secrets though, even by revealing some things, they end up surprising and delighting audiences in new ways. I think they also give the general public a greater appreciation of what goes into making good magic. 

Apart from headlining at The Rio in Las Vegas, they have had a smash hit television series since 2011 called Penn & Teller: Fool Us. They also have made a slew of other television appearances and have performed internationally throughout their career.

Jeff McBride (American) (born 1959)

Jeff burst onto the magic scene in the early 1980’s. He featured a never-before-seen blend of dazzling sleight of hand skills blended with kabuki theatre movement and mask techniques. Jeff’s early career took him to venues including the Radio City Music Hall. He opened for performers including Diana Ross and Tom Jones. He also holds numerous prestigious awards from major magic organisations including ‘Lecturer of the Year’ from the Academy of Magical Arts (The Magic Castle). The Magic Circle in London called Jeff McBride ‘Possibly the most influential magician of our time’.

Apart from Jeff’s unforgettably theatrical and skilful magic performances, his other extraordinary contribution to the legacy of magic is through his school, The McBride Magic and Mystery School in Las Vegas. I have studied with him since 2015 and he has also served as magic consultant on my theatre magic show. Jeff’s knowledge of diverse specialisations in magic is profound, be it mentalism, stage magic, close-up magic or manipulations. His contribution to magic literature and tutorial videos is extensive and covers technique as deeply as it does performance skills and showmanship. Jeff’s place on my list of the best magicians combines all the above with his singular generosity in inspiring magicians around him to push their limits and create great magic. 

Thanks for coming along.  Say hello and drop me a note in the comments below. 
I hope to see you again after a few more turns in the trail.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *